There is no doubt that smoke detectors save millions of lives every year. According to Fire Protection Association (FPA) Australia, most fire-related injuries and deaths happen in residential homes.
The fires develop faster due to the materials commonly present in most homes. These materials also reduce the time people inside a residential building have to escape the fire.
Let’s explore the two types of smoke detectors, how they work, and their pros and cons to help you determine the best one for your home.
What a Smoke Detector Does
Smoke detectors sense fires by identifying small particles in the air through different technologies. If the particles exceed a particular threshold, the sensor signals the alarm to produce a warning so you and your loved ones can be safe.
Smoke detectors can sense flaming, fast-burning fires and smouldering, slow-burning fires.
The Two Types of Smoke Detectors
There are two different types of smoke detectors. The optical smoke detector functions like an electronic nose, while the ionisation detector works like an electronic eye.
How a Photoelectric Smoke Detector Works
The photoelectric smoke detector has a light-emitting diode (LED) that shoots an invisible, infrared light beam into a chamber.
The chamber has an electronic light detector that produces electricity when light reaches it. There’s an electronic circuit that monitors the photocell.
The light beam won’t reach the detector if no smoke is present. However, if there’s a fire, the smoke enters the chamber and disperses light beams that enter the photocell. The circuit then triggers, causing the alarm to produce a high-pitch warning.
- Photoelectric smoke detectors react faster to fires in the early smouldering stages before they produce flames.
- There are fewer false alarms caused by shower or cooking steam
- They are safer to use because they have no radioactive materials
- Photoelectric smoke detectors can be expensive to maintain due to their sensitivity to insects and dust particles.
- They need more current to function, so you’ll need a 110-volt power source
How an Ionisation Smoke Detector Works
The ionisation smoke detector is the most common type. It uses some chemistry to identify strange or unusual molecules coming inwards, such as smoke.
The smoke detector has an open ionisation chamber. The chamber has americium, a radioactive element. It constantly produces small radioactive particles that enter the detection chamber.
They bump into air particles, turning them into positively and negatively charged ions. The electrons and ions move between two electrodes.
If the electrons and ions remain in motion, the current runs continuously between electrodes. However, if there’s a fire, the smoke particles flood the detector and jam the ionisation chamber.
The smoke particles attach to the ions and cut off the electric current. The detector’s circuit identifies the change and signals the alarm.
- Ionisation smoke detectors are unaffected by the standard shower and cooking steam
- They react faster to fast-spreading or flaming fires
- More affordable than photoelectric smoke detectors
- They detect fires with little visible smoke faster than photoelectric smoke detectors
- The mechanism is more vulnerable to false alarms, so more people intentionally disable them
- They respond slower to smouldering fires
- Radioactive materials can make them unsafe
- Most suitable for rooms with highly combustible materials such as flammable liquids and cleaning products
Fire can start at various places in your home and rapidly spread to cause devastating injuries and losses. Installing a smoke detector may not entirely prevent dangerous fires, but it’s the first line of defence for you and your loved ones.
Whichever type you prefer, you’ll need a licensed electrician to help install your new smoke detector.